HomeTVOne Life to LiveWho Would You Lather?: Ryan Phillippe vs. Justin Hartley Luke Kerr August 12, 2008 One Life to Live, Smallville, Who Would You Lather? 3 Comments Who would you lather, former One Life to Live star Ryan Phillippe or former Passions star Justin Hartley? Want to vote on more "Who Would You Lather?" polls? Visit the Who Would You Lather page for more. Who would your lather? Who Would You Lather?: Ryan Phillippe vs. Justin Hartley Justin Harltey (75%, 547 Votes) Ryan Phillippe (25%, 182 Votes) Total Voters: 729Vote Loading ... 3 Responses sueboo54321 August 13, 2008 Just wondering why we are never really given the option to choose neither. Log in to Reply season1217 August 13, 2008 Ha Ha! Good one sueboo54321. Log in to Reply dsrbroadway August 14, 2008 Why isn’t this a weekly quiz? Log in to Reply Leave a Reply Cancel Reply You must be logged in to post a comment.