HomeTVGeneral HospitalWould You Like To See Erin Hershey Presley as the New Sarah on OLTL? Jamey Giddens October 20, 2008 41 Comments Could Port Charles—aka Lucy the Abdomenizing Vampire Slayer— alum Erin Hershey Presley (ex-Alison) add a little more "flash" to the role of Tina Lord’s daughter Sarah on One Life to Live now that Justis Bolding is out? TV Guide Canada’s Nelson Branco seems to think so. Branco has the lovely blonde on his Casting Couch for this week’s Nelson Ratings. You won’t believe which soap role this daytime dreamsicle lost out on. Click here to find out! 41 Responses Jillian Bowe October 20, 2008 Its too bad she didn’t get the View gig…… Log in to Reply season1217 October 20, 2008 I don’t see her lasting up against those ravenous wolves but I could be wrong. ________________________ //**It’s the writing, stupid!**\\ Log in to Reply Jamey Giddens October 20, 2008 I wish Babs would retire and Katie Couric could be lead moderator for The View. She would simply shame that silly Lizzie Britches into being quiet while she sits there and plays Barbie and Ken. Log in to Reply season1217 October 20, 2008 I never understood why Barbara Walters is on that panel. She never really expresses her views on anything. I mean, just be executive producer and deal w/ the show behind the scenes. ________________________ //**It’s the writing, stupid!**\\ Log in to Reply Jillian Bowe October 20, 2008 J, they need my ULTIMATE She-ro on that show one day to shush that heifer… OPRAH! O would forget her new way of life and get hood on that cow. Log in to Reply dellygrim October 20, 2008 I liked E.H. Presley on PC and her name gets brought up for every vacant role and there have been some I think she’d have been good for but I don’t want to see her as Sarah. I’d like to see Sarah taken in a new direction while they are recasting. I think EHP could definitely play the kind of Sarah we’ve been seeing but I have no interest in that. Is the current Alison leaving ATWT? I really like her but if she is gone I’d rather see Lauren Woodland (ex Brittany Hodges Marsino Y&R) Log in to Reply season1217 October 21, 2008 You’re not an Oprah fan, Jilian?! I guess you didn’t drink any of her MonaVie/kool-aid! ________________________ //**It’s the writing, stupid!**\\ Log in to Reply Jillian Bowe October 21, 2008 What’s wrong with being an O fan? I love me some Oprah so back it up seasons! You can trash talk Hasslecrack all ya want but O………. Those are fighting words there! Log in to Reply season1217 October 21, 2008 I misread you comments, you do like Oprah. Sorry, Jillian but there is only so much of the look into my eyes and do as a say mess I can take. ________________________ //**It’s the writing, stupid!**\\ Log in to Reply Jillian Bowe October 21, 2008 *LOL* Its ok. Yes my Oprah (she’s a friend in my head like Auntie Wendy says) and I betcha if she sat in on the View she’d forget she’s on TV and go straight HOOD on Hasslecrack. Log in to Reply daisyclover1938 October 21, 2008 Isn’t Erin a little too old to be playing OLTL’s Sarah? I wouldn’t mind her playing another Sarah…GH’s Sarah Webber. I’d love to see her and KeMo back onscreen together Log in to Reply Jamey Giddens October 21, 2008 Dont you even speak my Oprah’s name in the same breath with that Wendy Tranny! LOL Log in to Reply Chrystie-Delancey October 21, 2008 Personally, I too would like to see her on GH and to be reunited with Kelly Monaco. I think her teeth/facial expressions are similar to Claire Coffee and that she would make a good sibling for Nadine, but I would take her in any capacity. I would say I was sad to see Kiko A leave his role as Stanford but he might not have the chemistry with Alison a second time around. Maybe they could pair her with Matt. Log in to Reply season1217 October 21, 2008 If GH was interested in showing Quartermaines she could be Rebecca Holt, Jimmy Lee’s daughter. ________________________ //**It’s the writing, stupid!**\\ Log in to Reply Jillian Bowe October 21, 2008 *LOL* Hey now. O’s my friend in my head. And you leave Wendy alone J! She did too check those heifers from the Real Housewives of ATL today. Log in to Reply Agim87 October 21, 2008 Nelson or anyone, are they recasting Sarah or is the character leaving with Justis and heaven forbid Tina? If so i think Martha Madison would be fierce as Sarah and reunite her with Farah.Or even Marcy Rylan, hell i wouldnt even mind seeing Liza Huber in the role. Nelson i have a question for u or if anyone else knows this, is Carolyn Hinsey really fired from SOD, cuz every week she still has her terrible its only my opinion column and i thought she was fired in August or is she just writing it till the end of the year cuz i cant stand her!! When is she leaving so i can enjoy my subscription again. Nelson and Jamie, u know i lov ya, but ive gotta say something, i have to respectfully disagree about Marnie Schulenberg’s Alison. I know Jamie doesnt like her and every week she is on Nelson’s person to avoid like the plague. I need reasons why u guys dont like her. I have better people for that list like Briannne Mongrief’s Coldby, but thats another story. I happen to like Marnie way better than that previous Ali, Jessica Dunphy. She was so annoying onscreen and there has to be a reason they didnt bring her back. I like Marnie’s chemistry with Susan and Emily, and i am loving her with Casey, Chris and Aaron another story, i dont think she really loved them. I do wish she died her hair back blonde though. I cant wait to see Ali and Casey involved in the Nuke story this week. Also thank God they dropped that Parker and Liberty story though, or Pukerty. I like the actors, but it was gross. The actor was 15 and the actress is 22, is that even legal. I just felt gross watching it, anyone else feel that way. Anyway thanks for letting me voice my opinion and let me know what u think. BTW the actress who Played Abby on Days Ashley Benson is on CSI Miami right now. Log in to Reply elbugten October 21, 2008 I loved E H-P as PC’s Alison, but I think she’s too old to play Sarah. I think until OLTL figures out what it wants to do with Sarah, they should let the character rest offscreen for awhile. Sarah has to have some sass, like Natalie. She is Tina’s daughter, and used to be in a rock band, for heaven’s sake! Instead of being all “I love you Mom!” to Tina she should be mad as hell with her for abandoning her! I like Justis, I really do, but can you seriously picture her rocking out? Adrienne Leon would’ve worked for the part, but other than that, I can’t imagine any other actress currently on daytime in the role. Wait, maybe Jennifer Landon? Or, one more even wilder thought, what about getting Erin Torpey to come back as Sarah? They could make her a redhead to look more like Tina, and Sarah and Jessica are cousins which would explain the resemblance. Plus, Erin can sing if they ever decide to bring “Flash” back. Log in to Reply THEBEST October 21, 2008 I live for Erin Hershey Presley! I would take her as Sarah ANY DAY!!!! ***///The Hunt 4 Dixie Martin Is On!\\\*** Log in to Reply elle October 21, 2008 I had hoped she would get the Babe role, when they were recasting at the time on AMC. I think she might be too old for Sarah as well. Log in to Reply SusieQ October 21, 2008 I think she’d make a good Sarah, but honestly, she just needs to get hired by someone, somewhere!!! It’s such a waste that she doesn’t have a gig right now!! Log in to Reply sueboo54321 October 21, 2008 Ooh, I l really like Erin. She and Lucky would look good together on GH. He deserves to have someone new and not the town’s sloppy seconds. Log in to Reply Jamey Giddens October 21, 2008 Sloppy Seconds??? Sam is more Sloppy Fifteenth’s at this point! Log in to Reply elbugten October 21, 2008 If they brought Erin back to GH, why couldn’t she still be Alison? that’s where the character started; her Grandma was on the hospital board and was a friend of the Q’s. Alison was a candystriper at first. Oh wait. if KeMo is Sam rather than Livvie, and Jay Pickett is Garcia rather than Frank Scanlon, I guess Erin would have to be someonoe other than Alison, too, lol! Log in to Reply season1217 October 21, 2008 “Sloppy Seconds??? Sam is more Sloppy Fifteenth’s at this point!” ________________________ THIS from a Brooke Logan fan! ________________________ //**SIZ FOR LIFE**\\ Log in to Reply daisyclover1938 October 21, 2008 Holy Crow, can I be safe from the Sam/KeMo hate anywhere on this site?? I only watched a little bit of Port Charles on SoapNet, but loved Erin and Kelly’s frenemies chemistry – and it would be great to see them together again. Log in to Reply daisyclover1938 October 21, 2008 Oh and aunti2egl said Bitchy Boobs, which is funny! It’s not really accurate because Sam’s not a bitch, but I think I’m going to have to steal that nickname some day for another character Log in to Reply sueboo54321 October 21, 2008 Holy Crow, can I be safe from the Sam/KeMo hate anywhere on this site?? I only watched a little bit of Port Charles on SoapNet, but loved Erin and Kelly’s frenemies chemistry – and it would be great to see them together again. _______________________________________________________ Now, I don’t in a any way, shape, or form dislike Kelly Monaco. I do have to ask. If people like her so much, why do they give her a nickname that sounds like radiation therapy? Just wondering. I stopped watching Port Charles when the vampires started showing up. I didn’t mind Kelly Monaco on there. I liked Erin. It is too long ago for me to really remember their relationship. They could bring Erin on as just about anyone on GH. I don’t think anyone would care that she looks a lot like Allison. Claudia was once Carly. It is no big deal. I say bring her back. Give the girl a job. Log in to Reply daisyclover1938 October 21, 2008 I do have to ask. If people like her so much, why do they give her a nickname that sounds like radiation therapy? Just wondering. Soooo not funny… Log in to Reply Jamey Giddens October 21, 2008 Brooke Logan is a slut, granted. But she’s a GOOD slut, i.e. she marries her men and takes 51 percent of their company. Sam on the other hand is a dumb slut. She doesn’t even have the good sense to get anybody down the aisle. Nothing worse than a slut with no ambition! Log in to Reply sueboo54321 October 21, 2008 Oh. that isn’t true. Sham married a whole bunch of guys under an assumed name. You are right. She wasn’t bright enough to marry them using her own name and divorce them all legal like. She married them and stole their money and skipped town. She’s a stupid slutty opportunistic con artist with no fashion sense. Log in to Reply daisyclover1938 October 21, 2008 She’s a stupid slutty opportunistic con artist with no fashion sense. as opposed to Liz who is a stupid slut that keeps getting knocked up by men that aren’t her husband, dresses like a teenager and whose poofy hair makes her look like a giant Q-tip Log in to Reply season1217 October 21, 2008 Break out the vaseline! A fights a brewin’! ________________________ //**SIZ FOR LIFE**\\ Log in to Reply sueboo54321 October 22, 2008 from wikipedia - “Slut or slattern is a pejorative term for a person who is deemed sexually promiscuous.” Who would actually consider a single working mother with two children, who rarely gets a chance to finish a conversation with her one true love let alone consummate, to be a slut? Liz isn’t getting any. Her entire sexual history on the show consists of a one night stand with Zander, her long term relationships with Lucky, a marriage to Rik (unfortunate), and having slept with Jason only a handful of times. She is the least promiscuous female on the show besides Robin and Kristina. Epiphany is getting more action. Liz has absolutely fabulous hair and perfect skin. She is beautiful. Log in to Reply season1217 October 22, 2008 Katherine Kelly Lang is perhaps one of the most beautiful women in daytime but Brooke is still a slut. Last time I checked flawless skin isn’t a sign of virginity! There are a lot of pimply faced virgins. LOL! ________________________ //**SIZ FOR LIFE**\\ Log in to Reply daisyclover1938 October 22, 2008 What does poofy hair and nice skin have to do with it?? LOL! So what if the hoochie has access to clearasil? A tramp is a tramp – and smearing on globs of gooey lip gloss doesn’t change that (what is it they say about putting lipstick on a pig??) As soon as the little hussey has marital problems she screws her closest male friend (all in the name of “comfort” LOL!) She’s been impregnated by 4 different men (3 out of those 4 times she was married to a *different* man), has had 2 Who’s The Daddy storylines, and *begs* the local mobster to have sex with her even though it’s going to endanger her kids! Yeah, she hasn’t gotten any lately – because she keeps getting R-E-J-E-C-T-E-D. What’s worse than being a slut? Being a slut that no one wants to have sex with! Liz can’t even GIVE it away!! Sam and Liz are both slutty (but no one is more of a slut then Sonny)! Log in to Reply season1217 October 22, 2008 “What is it they say about putting lipstick on a pig??” ________________________ Don’t bring Babe into this! Show some respect for the dead!:P ________________________ //**SIZ FOR LIFE**\\ Log in to Reply season1217 October 22, 2008 THE HOOCHIE HAS ACCESS TO CLEARASIL?! WHAT’S WORSE THAN BEING A SLUT? BEING A SLUT THAT NO ONE WANTS TO HAVE SEX WITH?! Excellent rebuttal. ROTFL And Sonny’s not a slut… he’s just looking for love in all the wrong places. ________________________ //**SIZ FOR LIFE**\\ Log in to Reply daisyclover1938 October 22, 2008 And Sonny’s not a slut… he’s just looking for love in all the wrong places. My bad Season, you’re right! Btw, I’m totally stealing that for my defense of Sam, lol Log in to Reply aunti2egl October 21, 2008 I’d love to see Erin as Sarah…I know I know. But I MISS MY ERIN. We (or I) haven’t seen her since PC ended and she is SO much better than bitchy boobs KeMo (sorry wasn’t a Livvie fan and I’m not a Sam fan). If you could’ve measured my disgust when I found out KeMo was coming to the “mother ship” after PC was canceled it would’ve measured UP THERE HIGH on the richter scale! LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!! Yeh. So I would SO love to see my Erin come to OLTL and if not as Sarah then anyone, someone new….just bring her, bring Brian too……..and the kid. LOL I wanna see ‘em. Log in to Reply aunti2egl October 21, 2008 Yeh Kiko and Erin were hot together. Ahhh poor Stan, too bad he isn’t around anymore. Wonder where Brian Gaskill is? They could bring him around. Well if it’s not OLTL then I’d love to see Erin on GH. But they’d have to ax KeMo. Just sayin’….I’ve had enough of Li.I mean Sam. LOL I haven’t even tuned in yesterday and seriously doubt I want to even waste my finger ff….? Log in to Reply aunti2egl October 22, 2008 That’s an idea…she could be Ali..but wait..I suffer from CRS (at will) LOL who was her grandma? Oh wait…….Amanda Barrington? Right…Didn’t Jamal used to call her granny? Whatever he called her that cracked me up. Which brings me to ………you forgot that Kiko was Stan. LOL!!! Log in to Reply Leave a Reply Cancel Reply You must be logged in to post a comment.