HomeTVThe Young and The RestlessWho Has the Freshest Face?: Lily vs. Colleen Luke Kerr April 15, 2009 The Young and The Restless 24 Comments Jack Abbott (Peter Bergman) is pushing for Colleen Carlton (Tammin Sursok) to become the next "Fresh Face of Jabot" while Nikki Newman (Melody Thomas Scott) is offering former "Fresh Face" model, Lily Winters (Christel Khalil), an opportunity to reboot her modeling career at Restless Style. Which got me thinking… Who has the Freshest Face? Who Has the Freshest Face?: Lily vs. Colleen Lily (71%, 603 Votes) Colleen (29%, 249 Votes) Total Voters: 852Vote Loading ... 24 Responses justangel24 April 15, 2009 This is hard, They are both beautiful. I bet this storyline could mess up their friendship. HE HE HE! I remember Lily talking crap about her best friend being the fresh face. I can TOTALLY see it messing up their friendship. Lily might have another enemy in the midst. I would like to see a knock out drag out fight between them. We need a good catfight. And Lily should act more like her Mommie Dearest. So I guess my answer is they should both be fresh faces and watch the claws come out. Log in to Reply Jamey Giddens April 15, 2009 Both are pretty girls, but Colleen has more spunk and acts more like a young, fun girl in her twenties. Log in to Reply purplebraids April 15, 2009 Why not have crossover storyline with B&B and have Steffy be the Fresh Face the only risen I say that is because she needs a job and it would be good for both companys and shows. :star .So Ididn`t vote for Liy or Colleen. Log in to Reply hunterforrester April 15, 2009 My ass is more beautiful. Log in to Reply season1217 April 15, 2009 I vote Lily. Log in to Reply THEBEST April 15, 2009 LMAO! Nelson is a fool! But, yeah…neither. Log in to Reply goyankees April 15, 2009 Colleen. She’s an Abbott so it only makes sense. Besides, Lily’s too busy being an Idiot these days to work. Butting into everyone else’s lives is very time consuming…. Log in to Reply david46208 April 15, 2009 Colleen has a booble head..lol I prefer Lily as the Fresh face. Log in to Reply Luke Kerr April 15, 2009 Colleen may be a fresh face, but by time Victor gets done with her she won’t be. Log in to Reply Jenny April 15, 2009 Lily Log in to Reply Jamey Giddens April 15, 2009 DIdn’t old Kevin give one of these so-called fresh candidates VD? Log in to Reply hunterforrester April 15, 2009 I’m so sick of soaps making local citizens major MODELS/spokeshairmodels. HIRE A REAL MODEL, people. Soaps should offer the prize to AMERICA’s NEXT TOP MODEL’s winner to star on their show. Log in to Reply ktuc April 15, 2009 Between these two hair models, unfortunately, I’d have to go with CK’s Lily. The only pose I’ve ever seen either of these actresses do is the ‘hands on hips’ pose. Neither are model worthy material! You would think that Colleen would be the better choice given that she has always been more spunky than Lily although, with the current insipid actress that occupies the role, she is now a bland character! Hunterforrester: you are right, they should let Tyra be the model since Eva at least knows how to model. Log in to Reply season1217 April 15, 2009 Didn’t old Kevin give one of these so-called fresh candidates VD? Yup. He gave one VD and tried to char-broil the other. Log in to Reply daisyclover1938 April 16, 2009 Is this “Fresh Face of Jabot” or “Bland Face of Jabot”? They’re both blah. I vote for hunterforrester’s ass. Log in to Reply Chrystie-Delancey April 16, 2009 I would give the edge to Colleen partly because Tammin is newer to Y&R. However, if I would rather see either Abby, Amber, or even Jana put to more use. I think all three women have more to offer as far as looks. I usually think brunettes are prettier, but Amber and Abby have very pretty hair and Jana is very classy and would make a very good model. Log in to Reply kennethzach April 16, 2009 Neither of these girls are good “FRESH FACES” Log in to Reply mll1206 April 16, 2009 we need a selection for NEITHER! Log in to Reply paige444 April 16, 2009 Ok, isn’t this the Fresh Face of Jabot, a contest requiring no experience but a “gal next door” sort of look? IMO, given that both are beautiful and satisfy the “no experience” requirement, both in theory, could qualify. If I have to choose one it is Lily. Like it or not, there is something about CK’s Lily that epitomises the definition of radiance and thus, beauty. It is what it is! Tyra (EM), though some may deem her to be the obvious choice, let’s face it, she cannot act. For now, let EM just stick to one thing at a time – let’s start with acting first, then, if needs be, modeling can come into play! Not meant to offend – peace! Log in to Reply cornelison April 16, 2009 Has anyone noticed Red’s face lately? She looks like she had minor cosmetic surgery. A matter of fact she no longer has those bags under her eyes. Surgeon did a great job! Smokin’ Red! Log in to Reply purplevinyl87 April 16, 2009 As much as I hate Lily’s valley girl behind, I have to say she is prettier than Colleen. Log in to Reply GG April 16, 2009 No competition Christel/Lily is gorgeous nothing against Colleen though. Log in to Reply monamis April 16, 2009 Both gorgeous girls, really the best looking on the show! When it comes to fresh face, I think Lily has that advantage because of the natural glow to her skin and the princess jasmine eyes that make her look innocent. Colleen is more of a vixen, likely to seduce your husband. Not a fresh face. Love them both immensely though! Log in to Reply tamxxx April 17, 2009 I think both of them are beautiful but i would say Colleen is more beautiful because she has very pretty hair, eyes,nice skin etc. But this storyline isnt realistic for both of them so i didnt vote. And i love them both very much! so i cant vote Log in to Reply Leave a Reply Cancel Reply You must be logged in to post a comment.