Victoria vs. Ashley: Who Should Stitch Choose on The Young and the Restless? (POLL)





How would you contend with your hunky, doctor crush dating your ex-stepdaughter/sister-in-law? Perfume princess Ashley Abbott (Eileen Davidson) faces just such a dilemma this week on CBS Daytime's The Young and the Restless.

After Abby (Melissa Ordway) and Tyler's (Redaric Williams) engagement party, Ash makes a beeline to the hospital, with Stitch (Sean Carrigan) on the brain. Little does she know, Stitch is already offering up his bedside manner to a newly-separated-from-Billy (David Tom) Victoria (Amelia Heinle). Awk-ward. 

We know Davidson's latest Genoa City visit is pretty much a drive-by, but if Ashley were to stick around, who would you want Stitch to be with — Victoria or Ashley?

Victoria vs. Ashley: Who Should Stitch Choose on The Young and the Restless? (POLL)

  • Ashley (62%, 476 Votes)
  • Victoria (38%, 291 Votes)

Total Voters: 767

Vote

Loading ... Loading ...

15 Responses

  1. Profile photo of pferrando
    pferrando

    I chose Ashley because she’s a much missed character on the show, and we need her back.

    Similar to Jess not being on contract, I’d rather have Eileen back part time to beef up the Abbotts and also Jabot story lines.

    And she had instant chemistry with Ben.

  2. Profile photo of harlee490
    harlee490

    Ashley baby! The writers are writing the Newmans correctly and one of things that is positive stories.

    We need Ashley back fulltime and start writing the Abbotts in a correct manner with family drama bringing Jill into the family more…Abbotts are so opposite of the Newmans and it would be a great contrast as Bill always wrote both families.

    Jamey called it and would in not be fun TV to watch step mommy vs. step daughter both vying for Ben’s attention and both sleeping with Ben at the same time ;)

  3. Profile photo of SZima
    SZima

    I don’t want him with either one! Victoria is boring as hell and Ashley is really too old for him. Seems like Ben would be interested in Abby rather then Ashley.
    Why can’t they put him with someone else? We all know Nick & Sharon are going to blow up one of these days. Maybe Ben should be the one to pick up the pieces.
    I don’t know, but I don’t like the choices!

  4. Profile photo of CarlyCfan
    CarlyCfan

    In how many love triangles these two have been together? Cole, Brad and now Ben? Nikki needs some Stitch lovin too, as Victoria and her mamma love to share even more than Victoria and her step-mom. For all shit people give Sharon because she married all the Newman men, people don’t talk enough about how the Newman women always screw the same men. Deacon is also dicked down both Nikki and Vicky.

  5. Profile photo of kgdallas
    kgdallas

    I hate the way they bring Ashley back for the 2-3 episode stints. Quit teasing us and bring her back FT or not at all, but since she’s reprising her role on DOOL we know that’s not going to happen. I think they’re realizing what a huge mistake they made letting her go in the first place. Made no sense whatsoever! IMO

  6. Profile photo of harlee490
    harlee490

    [quote=fmat55]I choose Victoria. Eileen needs to go back to DOOL where she shines brightly.[/quote]

    To each their own respectfully…but Eileen needs to come back to YR where she belongs :) Eileen always has came home soon or later to play her defining, iconic character of Ashley Abbott. :bigsmile:

  7. Profile photo of ChrisGa
    ChrisGa

    [quote=harlee490][quote=fmat55]To each their own respectfully…but Eileen needs to come back to YR where she belongs :) Eileen always has came home soon or later to play her defining, iconic character of Ashley Abbott. :bigsmile:[/quote]

    I would agree with that….IF she’s written properly. The last regime did her zero favors in that department and DAYS gave her primo story for a solid year before she decided to take a break. If they actually gave her the writing and story, I would love to see one of my all-time favorite soap characters played by one of my all-time favorite soap actresses back in GC full-time. :)

  8. Profile photo of stoney07
    stoney07

    ASHLEY!!!!!

    I think they have incredible chemistry. And this past stint with Ashley and the one before this made me wonder how this new regime would write Ashley Abbott. She seems a lot more interesting in these drive by visits than she was with the last regime when she was on contract. So IDK. I wish we could get Ashley full time again :( In that sexy ass lab coat with a clipboard in her hand and glasses at the tip of her nose with slightly curled hair.

    sorry…maybe I got a little carried away.
    *goes to take a cold shower*

  9. Profile photo of pferrando
    pferrando

    She looked absolutely fantastic and owned those scenes.

    What the hell is wrong with these writers. Bring her back on a more regular basis if she’s available.

    It would help balance the Newmans and Abbotts again, and make both families strong.

  10. Profile photo of harlee490
    harlee490

    It would balance both iconic families that has served YR so well the last 30 years. What hell with CBS\Sony\JFP\writers to demand ED back and show all a story bible for Ashley in story…dumbasses!

    Newman\Abbotts are contrast families which is how Bill created to balance out the canvas.

Leave a Reply