Which One Life to Live Transplant Will You Miss The Most on General Hospital?



With Todd (Roger Howarth), Starr (Kristen Alderson) and John (Michael Easton) all reportedly leaving General Hospital (at least temporarily), we have to ask:

Which Llanview transplant will you miss most when they leave Port Charles?

Todd Manning
62% (2031 votes)
Starr Manning
12% (381 votes)
John McBain
26% (845 votes)
Total votes: 3257

Comments

Jabot1991's picture
Member since:
20 June 2011
Last activity:
21 weeks 1 day

I vote neither.. They serve NO purpose on GH.. I'm happy they are going back to OLTL, they belong on that show.

Member since:
17 July 2009
Last activity:
6 days 9 hours

John works much better on GH than OLTL. Todd will shine on either show. He and Starr (but moreso Todd) are more integral to OLTL than John. Of course, GH can, has, and will do just fine without any of them. However, I'd rather see McBam play out than Jolie.

JasamForever's picture
Member since:
29 December 2009
Last activity:
7 hours 26 min

None. That should have been an option. Wink

Member since:
23 October 2008
Last activity:
14 weeks 6 days

It's a tie between Todd and Starr, I prefered John more on OLTL than GH but I liked Starr better on GH. Her and Todd made me tolerate two of my least favorite GH characters...Michael and Carly. I used to want those two to get another bullet in the head.

Member since:
28 January 2009
Last activity:
1 week 5 days

None.

Maybe they can eventually bring Easton back as Caleb but don't think John, Todd or Starr fit on GH when all their history is one OLTL.

Member since:
15 January 2009
Last activity:
2 weeks 3 days

None

nysam's picture
Member since:
28 October 2008
Last activity:
4 hours 53 min

This is a good gauge for who PP should keep on OLTL. Looks like they should let Starr remain on GH.

david46208's picture
Member since:
15 January 2009
Last activity:
4 days 6 hours

None! Now I would suggests they invest in rebuilding the Ward's. They can make Justice's (Henry Simmons as the recast) death be a fake. Hey this is the show that had Ceaser Fason pretend to be Duke. Bring back a more mature Keesha (Daphnée Duplaix Samuel as the recast). They can say that Keesha and Shawn had a past together. Heck they could even make his son turn out to be her's and his's child. That could lead to a custody battle and to the start of a love triangle. Have Keesha and Alexis as nemeses.

nysam's picture
Member since:
28 October 2008
Last activity:
4 hours 53 min

David, that sounds great about the Wards. How about have the new gay nurse be Keesha and Shawn's son OR have it turn out that Keesha left town preggers and he is Keesha and Jason's son!

CarlyCfan's picture
Member since:
14 May 2009
Last activity:
2 days 8 hours

None really should have been an option, i won't miss any of them at all. I hope they never come back!

Member since:
17 October 2012
Last activity:
51 weeks 4 days

CarlyCfan wrote:
None really should have been an option, i won't miss any of them at all. I hope they never come back!

They will be back. This is temporary. They are using strong characters to tie up the storylines for Todd and John. They may even resolve the question of who really shot Victor and where he is, because Todd didn't kill him.

Member since:
6 July 2008
Last activity:
23 weeks 2 days

I won't miss Starr at all. The character is too young to be given the attitudes and actions she has. There is no joy and laughter in her. She is all wrong from Michael who needs someone with fire and life. She's also a busybody, always talking things over and giving advice (She reminds me of Maggie on Days of Our Lives) and then having to deal with her psychopath father who is too looney to be allowed out on his own. Todd is a hoot and a much needed addition to the population of Port Charles. I like John. He is nice and he's savy smart but he is wasted on the show. If he stays he is just going to be another shoulder for Sam to weep all over. Maybe Sam could go to Llanview too. I wouldn't miss her at all.

Member since:
3 February 2008
Last activity:
44 min 14 sec

I agree that "none" should be an option. Of all the OLTL characters (and my heart has always been OLTL, then GH, then AMC) these were the 3 I least would have picked to come to GH. I feel like Todd/Carly is just a retread of Todd/Blair. Starr has never worked on GH. I'm not a huge McPain fan, but he works with Sam, and I would've liked to see a Sam/John/Natalie triangle with a few good old fashioned cat fights and some hair pulling. I'm hoping that if John goes crawling back to Natalie in Llanview she gives him what for, and then Roxie gives him round two for doing her Nattie wrong! That story needs to be told on OLTL and the Victor "murder" arc needs to be resolved, with Todd there for that. Starr needs to look up the Ford brothers again. THAT's who KA has chemistry with.

Member since:
8 March 2012
Last activity:
1 week 2 days

Okay so PP couldn’t their act together and are now going to screw these actors over? What a complete mess!

Member since:
15 May 2012
Last activity:
1 year 8 weeks

None really. Never liked Starr. While Todd has been funny, I can live without a Todd/Carly 'romance'. While John and Sam could work, I'd rather send him back to Llanview so I won't have to suffer through a McBam/Gnat triangle. LOATHE the Gnat and don't want her on GH.

logan_echolls's picture
Member since:
3 August 2012
Last activity:
27 min 50 sec

GH needs John. Him and Sam are perfection. Starr...GOOD RIDDANCE!!!! Couldn't stand her self righteous behind. I will miss Todd. I loved his one liners but I won't miss him sniffing behind Carly.

Member since:
29 January 2009
Last activity:
2 weeks 3 days

All of those black ppl on GH at the same time? I'll believe it when i see it.

Member since:
29 January 2009
Last activity:
2 weeks 3 days

I'll miss McBain because I like him with Sam. But the pairing of Starr and Michael is excrutiatingly boring. And i like the character of Todd, but after watching him dominate OLTL for so long, I'm kind of tired of him.

aramis270's picture
Member since:
30 April 2010
Last activity:
1 year 10 weeks

None also...
After Cartini threw Johnny and CarJohn under the bus (pissing off a lot of viewers) to pimp Todd and Carly/Todd, I would find it hilarious if all was for nothing and RH/Todd was stuck with PP and never to come back.

We got AJ back and a lot of our GH faves. That is more than enough for me and should PP's OLTL keep only one of them, let them keep Todd, I can deal with John (as he is more watchable on GH than OLTL) and I can always FF Starr.

But I am very happy if I can get a glimpse of Dorian and Bo and Viki again on the OLTL reboot and I would be over the moon if Trevor Saint John could be back as Victor... If this happens, thank you PP. In the meantime, let's wait and see...

Windsor Heights's picture
Member since:
9 February 2012
Last activity:
7 weeks 1 day

Yes, there should have been another option. ALL.