Production sources tell the site that, while Sony execs "loved" him as a guest host, they "didn't think he was the right fit for the daily syndicated quiz show." The same reportedly went for other guest hosts.
TMZ stated that Sony only had meetings about hosting full-time with Mayim Bialik, subsequently announced as the host for spinoff and primetime specials, and EP Mike Richards. However, the studio apparently did speak with Burton about projects other than Jeopardy!, and those close to Burton informed the site the actor-director has "no hard feelings." He just wanted his opportunity to guest host, they added, which he gave "his all."